top of page
  • Madeline Eby

The Benefits and Drawbacks of Increasing Deductibles to Lower Commercial Auto Insurance Costs

Increasing deductibles can have both benefits and drawbacks when it comes to lowering commercial auto insurance costs. Here are some of the key points to consider:

Pros For Increasing Your Deductible

Lower Premiums

Increasing your deductible can lead to a decrease in the premiums you pay for commercial auto insurance. Insurance companies take on less risk when you have a higher deductible, which can result in lower rates for your policy. This reduction in premiums can help your business save money on insurance costs. However, it's important to balance the potential savings with the risk of higher out-of-pocket costs in the event of an accident.

Better Risk Management

Having a higher deductible in your commercial auto insurance policy can encourage better risk management practices by making you more responsible for accident costs. You may take extra precautions to avoid accidents and maintain your vehicles in good condition. This can result in fewer claims and lower insurance costs over time. Additionally, a focus on risk management can improve your reputation and increase your chances of winning business contracts. However, it's important to balance the potential benefits with the risk of higher out-of-pocket costs if an accident does occur.

Tailored policies

Increasing deductibles on commercial auto insurance policies can help companies tailor their coverage to meet their specific needs. By selecting a higher deductible, companies can control their costs and allocate their resources more effectively. Larger fleets or high-risk operations may benefit from higher deductibles, as they may be more capable of assuming the higher financial responsibility in the event of an accident. Conversely, smaller fleets or operations with lower risk may not require a higher deductible and may benefit from a lower premium instead. Careful consideration of the potential risks and benefits can help companies select the best deductible for their needs.

Tax Savings

Increasing auto insurance deductibles for commercial vehicles can provide businesses with an opportunity to save on taxes. The higher deductible reduces the premium paid, which the IRS considers a business expense that can be deducted from taxable income. As a result, companies that increase their deductible may be able to reduce their tax liability while still maintaining adequate insurance coverage. It's important to keep accurate records and ensure that the deductible meets the IRS requirements for business expense deductions. However, while tax savings can be a valuable benefit of increased deductibles, it's important to consider the potential risks and costs associated with higher out-of-pocket expenses in the event of an accident.

Cons For Increasing Your Deductible

Higher Out-of-Pocket Costs

While increasing your commercial auto insurance deductible can lead to lower premiums, it also means that you will have higher out-of-pocket costs in the event of an accident. Businesses must ensure they have enough cash on hand to cover the increased deductible, which can be a challenge for those with limited financial resources. Additionally, higher deductibles may discourage drivers from reporting minor accidents, as they may not want to bear the cost of the deductible. This can lead to delays in repairs and more significant issues down the line. Careful consideration of the risks and benefits is necessary when deciding to increase your commercial auto insurance deductible.

Reduced Coverage Per Accident

Increasing commercial auto insurance deductibles can lead to reduced coverage per accident, as companies are responsible for a larger share of the costs. If the damage from an accident exceeds the deductible amount, the company may have to pay for any remaining expenses out of pocket. This can lead to financial strain, especially for companies with limited resources. Additionally, some insurance policies may have a cap on coverage limits, which can further limit the protection companies receive in the event of an accident. Careful evaluation of coverage limits and deductibles is essential to ensure that companies have adequate protection while balancing the potential cost savings.

Increased Risk

One of the potential downsides of increasing your commercial auto insurance deductible is that it could lead to increased risk-taking. Drivers may be less likely to report minor incidents that fall below the deductible amount, which could lead to a higher chance of future accidents. This could result in higher costs in the long run, particularly if the unreported incidents lead to more significant issues. Additionally, if drivers take more risks due to the higher deductible, it could lead to higher insurance premiums over time. It's essential to balance the potential cost savings of a higher deductible with the risks associated with increased risk-taking and unreported incidents.

More Complex Claims

Increasing your commercial auto insurance deductible can make claims more complex and time-consuming. Companies may need to negotiate with their insurance company to ensure they receive the best possible payout, which can lead to longer wait times and additional obstacles. This process can be especially challenging for companies with limited resources or those who lack experience in navigating insurance claims. Moreover, the time spent negotiating and handling claims can divert resources and attention from other critical aspects of running a business. Companies must consider the potential complexities and additional administrative burden associated with higher deductibles when making their insurance decisions.

Overall, increasing deductibles can be an effective way to lower commercial auto insurance costs, but it's important to weigh the potential benefits and drawbacks carefully before making a decision. Consider your business's unique needs, your financial situation, and your risk tolerance before adjusting your deductible.

Work With CarrierHQ

Make sure you have an agent who knows transportation. Give CarrierHQ a call and get a quote today!

bottom of page